
Wind vs. Hail Damage on Roofs: How Adjusters Document Both
A lot of storms bring both. The hail hits the roof, and the wind that came with it lifts, creases, and tears shingles off the slopes facing the storm.
That puts two kinds of damage on one roof, and they don't look the same, happen in the same places, or get documented the same way. Mix them together in your photos and your notes, and the reviewer can't tell what caused what.
Here's how to tell wind and hail damage apart on a roof, and how to document both so your file holds up.
Wind vs. Hail Damage: The Quick Difference
Hail damage comes from impacts. Hailstones strike the roof and leave bruises, fractures, and granule loss scattered across the slopes facing the storm.
Wind damage comes from force. Wind gets under shingles, lifts them, and bends, creases, tears, or removes them. It usually shows up where wind can get a grip: edges, corners, rakes, ridges, and the slopes facing the wind.
What Hail Damage Looks Like
A bruise or soft spot that gives when you press it
Granule loss in a round pattern exposing fresh, dark asphalt
Sharp, crisp edges around the impact
A random pattern across the slope
Matching collateral: dented gutters, vents, AC fins, and screens
What Wind Damage Looks Like
Creased shingles, with a straight crease line across the shingle, often near the nail line
Missing shingles or missing tabs
Torn tabs or shingles bent back on themselves
Lifted shingles with broken seal strips
Exposed nail heads or underlayment where shingles are gone
Damage concentrated at edges, rakes, ridges, and corners
Wind collateral looks different too: fences leaning or down, tree limbs and debris, missing siding or soffit, and gutters pulled away from the fascia.
Where to Look for Each
Hail damage shows up across the slopes that faced the storm, usually spread across the whole slope.
Wind damage clusters where wind catches the roof: the windward slopes, the first few courses at the eaves, the rakes, the ridge, and the corners of the roof. A slope can have heavy hail and no wind damage, or the other way around.
That's why working every slope in the same order matters. You'll see the pattern of each kind of damage as you go.
How to Document Both
Use the same photo sequence you use on every hail claim, and capture wind damage at each stop along the way. If you don't have the sequence yet, download our free Hail Damage Photo Checklist.
1. Start the File
Risk photo
Address or house number
2. Exterior, Elevation by Elevation
Work front, right, rear, then left. On each elevation, photograph the overview, gutters, windows, and soft metals, and note damage or no damage.
On a wind and hail claim, add:
Missing or damaged siding, soffit, and fascia
Gutters pulled loose
Fences, trees, and debris, with the direction they fell
Shingles or debris on the ground near that elevation
Debris on the ground and the direction things fell help show which way the wind came from.
3. Roof Details
Number of roof layers
Drip edge present or not
Shingle gauge, or metal roof gauge
Pitch
4. Roof, Slope by Slope
Work front, right, rear, then left. On each slope, document hail and wind as two separate findings.
For hail:
Slope overview
Damage or no damage
Test square: wide, medium with chalk count, and a minimum of 3 hail impact close-ups with scale
For wind:
Each missing, creased, or torn shingle, marked with chalk
A wide shot showing where the wind damage is on the slope
Close-ups of creases, tears, and broken seal strips
A count of wind-damaged shingles on that slope
Then finish the slope with:
Roof components, with the count chalked next to each one
Look-alikes or prior repairs, if any
Mark Hail and Wind Differently
Use different chalk marks so your photos tell the story on their own. Many adjusters circle hail hits and mark wind-damaged shingles with a W or an X.
On each slope, write both counts in your notes, for example: Rear slope, 11 hail hits in test square, 6 wind-creased shingles. The slope tally on our free checklist has room for both.
Label Every Photo
Labels are where a lot of wind and hail files fall apart. A photo labeled "roof damage" doesn't tell the reviewer which peril caused it.
Label every photo with the slope, the type of damage, and the detail:
Rear slope, test square, 11 hail hits, chalk marked
Rear slope, 6 wind-creased shingles at eave
Left rake, 3 missing shingles, exposed underlayment
Watch for Wind Look-Look-Alikes
Not every lifted or missing shingle is storm damage. Before you call it wind, rule out:
Shingles that never sealed because of age, heat, or installation
High nailing, where nails sit above the nail line
Missing starter course at eaves and rakes
Thermal cracking or brittleness from age
Old repairs or shingles that were already missing
Photograph and note what you rule out, just like you do with hail look-alikes.
Why Separating Them Matters
Wind and hail damage may be handled differently depending on the policy, the carrier, and the storm. A slope that doesn't meet the hail threshold may still need repairs for wind damage, and the reverse is also true.
Your job is to document each one clearly and let the policy and the carrier's guidelines decide the rest. When your photos and notes separate wind from hail, the reviewer can make that call without calling you.
Common Mistakes
Labeling everything as "storm damage" or "roof damage"
Counting wind-creased shingles in the hail test square
Skipping the edges, rakes, and ridge where wind damage hides
Calling unsealed shingles wind damage without checking for age or installation issues
Forgetting wind collateral like fences, siding, and debris
Not counting wind-damaged shingles slope by slope
Master Hail and Storm Claims
Wind and hail claims reward adjusters who slow down and document each one separately. Work the same order on every roof, mark and label each peril, and your files will hold up in review.
Ready to go deeper? Adjuster Prep's Hail Claims course walks you through real storm inspections on asphalt and metal roofs, from collateral to test squares to the estimate. Explore it at AdjusterPrepd.com, and grab the free Hail Damage Photo Checklist to use on your next roof.


Comments